Policymakers Take Note: Population Growth is Easing in the Atlantic
Rishi Sondhi, Economist | 416-983-8806
Marc Ercolao, Economist
Date Published: July 18, 2024
- Category:
- Canada
- Provincial & Local Analysis
Highlights
- Canada’s Atlantic region is experiencing a notable moderation in population growth. This contrasts with the nation at a whole, whose population growth is still humming at multi-decade highs.
- Provincial governments’ lofty population projections, especially in 2025, are at risk of overshooting. This has the potential to put a damper on both household spending and overall economic growth, while also weighing on labour supply.
- Slower population growth would take some heat out of housing rental price growth and ease overall housing affordability concerns.
Recent immigrants have integrated comparatively well into Atlantic labour markets. - New federal immigration policy will work its way through the Atlantic region in various ways. However, no province is immune to the intended outcomes.
Population growth remains incredibly strong in the Atlantic Region. However, it is easing from sky-high rates, just as other parts of the country appear to be holding firm (Chart 1). We anticipate this trend towards slower population growth in the Atlantic will persist, marking a very important development for a region where economic growth has broadly benefitted more from recent population inflows. Consumer spending will be impacted, potentially flipping the script from the past few years when our internal data showed an outperformance compared to the rest of Canada. In fact, if population growth evolves more in line with what we expect versus what provincial governments are forecasting, then household spending growth across the region could be as much as 0.6 ppts lower next year than what’s implied by government projections. The construction sector will also be influenced, following a few years of very healthy gains. However, the impact could come with more of a lag as major projects are ongoing, and planned capital investments are robust in places like Nova Scotia, PEI, and New Brunswick.
Provincial policymakers should also take note, as slowing population growth implies downside risk to what are generally quite lofty growth projections for the year ahead (Chart 2). Indeed, in their latest budgets, the Atlantic provinces are projecting GDP growth of 3.3% next year (on a weighted average basis), twice as strong as our forecasts and over three times faster than the pace observed in 2022/2023, when the region’s population base really started expanding rapidly. Granted, part of this story reflects an assumed bounce back in Newfoundland and Labrador’s oil production, but the broader point still stands.
![Chart 1 shows population growth in the Atlantic region and Canada from Q1-2016 to present. Atlantic population growth peaked in Q3-2023 at 2.83% and has since fallen to a current 2.3%. For Canada as a whole, population growth is at its peak levels relative to the sample at 3.2%. Both Atlantic and Canadian population growth dropped to under 0.5% during the depths of the pandemic.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-1.png)
![Chart 2 shows population growth in the Atlantic region from 2018 to 2025, with 2024 and 2025 showing projected population growth for the provincial governments and TD Economics. In 2024 and 2025, the government see's population growth averaging 1.8% in the Atlantic, versus 1.7% for TD. The divergence comes in 2025, where TD Economics expects population growth of 1%, versus 1.6% for provincial governments. In 2023, population growth was 2.8% for the region, up from 2.2% in 2022. From 2015-2021, population growth in the region averaged 0.7%.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-2.png)
Housing Market Implications
On the face of it, implications for housing markets are obvious. Fewer people entering the region implies less demand for housing. Of course, what’s driving the population slowdown matters, too. Slower inflows of international migrants should bring welcome relief to a region where rents continue to surge (the simple average of annual rent inflation was 7% across the region in May according to the CPI), especially as construction of these types of units is on the rise.
The slowdown in interprovincial migration will also impact a very important source of ownership housing demand for the region. Attracted by a massive affordability advantage, the wave of interprovincial migrants over the past few years–with the largest share coming from Ontario–have bid up prices to a significant degree and eroded affordability in every market. In Nova Scotia and PEI, affordability has been stretched to near historic worsts, although the situation is somewhat better in New Brunswick and Newfoundland and Labrador (Chart 3). Fewer Canadians are now choosing to move into the region from elsewhere in the country, blunting a force that was propping up home prices while leaving other residents of the Atlantic in a much worse affordability situation. Against this backdrop, we see home price growth slowing in the region next year, even with interest rates likely to decline (Chart 4).
![Chart 3 shows TD Economics' housing affordability metric compared to its long-run average in NL, PE, NS, and NB, in 2024Q1. In 2024Q1, the housing affordability metric was 55% above its long-run average in PE, 47% above in NS, 35% above in NB and 12% below in NL. This means that housing affordability was significantly worse than its long-run average in PE, NS and NB and better than its long-term average in NL.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-3.png)
![Chart 4 shows the year-on-year change in average home prices in the Atlantic region from 2019 to 2025. In 2023, average home prices went up 2% in the Atlantic, down from 14% in 2022, an average of 16% in 2020/21, and 5% in 2019. In 2024 price growth is forecast at 5%, slowing to 4% in 2025.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-4.png)
Labour Market Implications
![Chart 5 shows the employment rates for immigrants that landed in Canada in the last five years between Atlantic provinces and Canada as a whole. From 2006 until 2018, employment rates in this immigrant category were roughly the same between Canada and the Atlantic provinces. From 2019 onwards, employment rates for immigrants in Atlantic provinces is higher, averaging 80% vs 75% in Canada.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-5.png)
Slowing population growth across Atlantic provinces can also disproportionately impact labour markets. As economies were recovering from the pandemic, migrants from both the international and interprovincial migration channels contributed positively to local labour supply and employment growth. The downturn in population growth hasn’t yet translated to a slowdown in labour force growth, though we do expect a more pronounced effect on the labour force next year.
In the period from 2020 to present, immigrants across the Atlantic provinces experienced relatively better labour market outcomes compared to the nation as a whole. For example, immigrants landed 5 years or earlier are now seeing higher employment rates since the pandemic-recovery years compared to Canada (Chart 5). Historically speaking, the unemployment rate of new immigrants in the Atlantic region has hovered below that of Canada’s. Chart 6 shows that immigrants in the Atlantic didn’t experience the 2020 pandemic spike in unemployment rates that immigrants in the rest of Canada saw. Beyond this, the unemployment rate for new immigrants has continued to decline. In other words, Atlantic provinces are showing they are better able to absorb the wave of newcomers even as labour force growth picked up in line with the rest of Canada. This is part of the reason why total unemployment rates in the Atlantic region are rising at a slower pace than the rest of the nation while GDP growth prospects remain on the brighter side. Labour markets have indeed cooled in the Atlantic region alongside those of other provinces. However, if population growth slows faster than expected against a backdrop of still elevated vacancy rates (Chart 7), it may delay a full rebalancing.
![Chart 6 shows The unemployment rates for immigrants (landed 5 years or earlier) in Canada and the Atlantic provinces since 2006. As of 2023, the immigrant unemployment rate in Canada is at 8.8% vs the Atlantic provinces at 7.3%.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-6.png)
![Chart 7 shows the job vacancy rates across the Atlantic provinces since Q1-2016. Between 2016 and 2019. In Newfoundland, the current job vacancy rate is 3.3% vs a peak rate of 3.8% and a 2016-2019 historical average of 1.9%. In PEI, the current job vacancy rate is 4.1% vs a peak rate of 5.4% and a 2016-2019 historical average of 2.7%. In Nova Scotia, the current job vacancy rate is 3.9% vs a peak rate of 5.0% and a 2016-2019 historical average of 2.5%. In New Brunswick, the current job vacancy rate is 3.6% vs a peak rate of 4.7% and a 2016-2019 historical average of 2.6%.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-7.png)
Source of the Slowdown
![Chart 8 shows net international, net interprovincial, and net total migration in the Atlantic region since 1992. As of Q1-2024, net total migration stands at around 14k people with 12.8k coming from international migration and 1.2k coming from interprovincial migration. This represents a pullback from a peak total net migration count of 20.9k in Q2-2023.](/domains/economics.td.com/images/reports/me/ca-pop-growth-atlantic/chart-8.png)
At a broad level, the deceleration of the Atlantic region’s population growth is being disproportionally driven by a slowdown in net interprovincial migration as opposed to international migration (Chart 8). At last count (Q1-2024), net interprovincial migration in the Atlantic provinces totaled just over 1,000 people, a significant pullback from the 5,000+ run rate between 2021 and 2022. Interprovincial migration is a relatively new source of population growth in the region. From 1992–2016 Atlantic provinces experienced net outflows through the interprovincial channel, so even the current (small) levels of inflows are greater than historical norms. Net international migration on the other hand is cooling but not to the same degree. Consistent with national level trends, non-permanent residents are still entering the country at a rapid clip in advance of federal policies aimed at curbing population flows.
On Federal policies, the effect of the government’s international student intake cap and non-permanent resident targets may impact Atlantic regions differently. For example, Newfoundland should be better insulated against the student cap, as is it the only Atlantic province to see their student permit allocations rise compared to 2023. The government’s intention to reduce the share of non-permanent residents to 5% of the total population may also come with varying implications. PEI for example, is currently the only Atlantic jurisdiction where non-permanent residents account for more than 5%, so non-permanent resident flows should slow quicker.
On the interprovincial side, flows in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia have more scope for a pullback as current levels are running well above their historical averages. The region as a whole however should continue to see modest positive interprovincial migration given the region’s affordability advantage, but these flows will remain well below peak levels in 2021 and 2022.
Bottom Line
While above-average levels of population growth are expected to persist in the Atlantic region in the very near-term, current trends are pointing to a faster slowdown in headcount growth compared to government estimates in 2025. While not necessarily a red flag, this does create a scenario for potential downside to economic growth via consumer spending and weaker job creation. At the same time, the housing market may benefit from slower rental price growth and easing affordability concerns. Federal government policies will work through the Atlantic region in various ways, with the common denominator being that all regions will see some form of population growth slowdown.
Disclaimer
This report is provided by TD Economics. It is for informational and educational purposes only as of the date of writing, and may not be appropriate for other purposes. The views and opinions expressed may change at any time based on market or other conditions and may not come to pass. This material is not intended to be relied upon as investment advice or recommendations, does not constitute a solicitation to buy or sell securities and should not be considered specific legal, investment or tax advice. The report does not provide material information about the business and affairs of TD Bank Group and the members of TD Economics are not spokespersons for TD Bank Group with respect to its business and affairs. The information contained in this report has been drawn from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate or complete. This report contains economic analysis and views, including about future economic and financial markets performance. These are based on certain assumptions and other factors, and are subject to inherent risks and uncertainties. The actual outcome may be materially different. The Toronto-Dominion Bank and its affiliates and related entities that comprise the TD Bank Group are not liable for any errors or omissions in the information, analysis or views contained in this report, or for any loss or damage suffered.
Download
Share: